In 2024, Colorado state officials announced a recall affecting 172 stores across the state. Batches of flower and pre-rolled joints from one grower exceeded mold and yeast limits. The losses were immense, including for companies that thought the money they were paying each year to insurance companies for premiums would provide, only to discover that coverage wasn’t there when it mattered most.

This is not an isolated story. Cannabis operators across the country pay high premiums for policies riddled with exclusions, resulting in enormous uninsured exposure to areas including product recall, regulatory action, business interruption, cyber liability, and directors and officers coverage. Section 280E makes every uninsured loss even more painful, with effective tax rates that can exceed 60 percent of gross income. The commercial insurance market has failed this industry structurally. Some operators are looking at captive insurance as a structural solution.

What Is a Captive Insurance Company?

A captive is a licensed insurance company that your business owns. Rather than paying premiums to a carrier that keeps the underwriting profit, the promise of a captive is that owners can accumulate reserves, keep the insurance company’s profit, and write policies covering risks that commercial markets refuse to underwrite. As such, it is worth looking at the pros and cons of forming a captive.

The Pros

Coverage for gaps no commercial carrier will fill. Control over your risk program, on your terms, based on your coverage and philosophy. Financial upside: underwriting profit stays in your business, not your carrier’s. Stability against volatile premium markets. Risk management discipline that improves your operations over time. And a powerful signal to investors and acquirers that your business is built with institutional-grade infrastructure, which is a meaningful advantage in capital raises and exit valuations.

The Cons                                                                                                                              Captives are not right for every operator. A single-parent captive typically requires $300,000 to $500,000 or more in annual premium spend (though this number may be much lower in the cannabis space). Group captives are accessible at much lower thresholds, sometimes $50,000 to $150,000. Upfront capitalization is required and varies by structure. This is a long-term strategy, not a quick fix, because benefits compound over years, not quarters. Ongoing regulatory compliance is real, though the right partner, such as 3F Captive Services, manages everything on behalf of clients.

Who Is a Good Candidate?

Multi-state operators with significant insurance spend. Businesses with stable, recurring cash flow. Operators frustrated by commercial coverage gaps, a pain known most acutely by those who have experienced an uninsured loss. Companies are thinking five to ten years ahead, including those positioning for a capital raise or exit.

Who Is Not Ready Yet?

Very early-stage operators with minimal insurance spend. Businesses with constrained liquidity. Companies with unresolved risk management or compliance problems. Operators looking for a quick tax benefit rather than a genuine insurance program. If this describes you today, the captive conversation is worth revisiting as your business matures.

Addressing the Common Objections

“It’s only for big companies.” Not anymore (group captives have significantly changed the economics of entry). “The IRS will come after me.” Properly structured captives are written into the tax code and have consistently withstood IRS scrutiny. “My broker handles this.” Most commercial brokers are not captive specialists (and often know nothing about captives), and their compensation model creates a structural disincentive to recommend one.

How the Process Works

Stage 1: An exploratory conversation. For example, 3F offers interested partners a no-fee assessment. Stage 2: A comprehensive feasibility study, including independent actuarial pricing of every policy, multi-year financial modeling, and full program design. Stage 3: Formation and licensing. Stage 4: Ongoing management, including actuarial reviews, regulatory filings, claims, and governance.

Before the next recall, claim, or regulatory action tests your coverage, it’s worth asking a simple question: Are you truly protected? A captive is not a fit for everyone, but for operators with the scale, discipline, and long-term mindset, it can turn risk into a strategic asset rather than an ongoing expense. The cost of doing nothing is often invisible, until it isn’t. The operators in Colorado learned that the hard way. The better path is to evaluate your structure now, while you still have the ability to choose it

Learn more at: 3F Captive Services — Cannabis Industry

The post Commercial Insurance Has Failed Cannabis. Here’s What’s Next appeared first on Cannabis Industry Journal.